Why Beijing's Bench Tribe is Sparking Controversy on the Subway

Beijing Subway Suggests Riders Forego Personal Chairs, Stools

Irene Li, Associate Editor | Nov 15, 2023 9:51 am | Add a comment | 174 reads

If you've ever taken a ride on the Beijing subway, you may have noticed individuals toting along small chairs or stools. These portable seats can sometimes be spotted in the crowded carriages, as passengers settle into their own mini perches during transit. However, transit authorities have recently made a statement suggesting passengers refrain from bringing these stools aboard, although they stopped short of issuing an outright ban, according to Beijing Daily.

Beijing Subway officials, along with security personnel, have discouraged this practice for various reasons. Primarily, those carrying these stools tend to take up more space than their standing counterparts. This becomes particularly problematic during rush hours when carriages are at their maximum capacity. The stools not only inhibit movement within the carriage but also pose potential challenges for others boarding or exiting the train. A stray stool could cause a trip, or, in the event of an abrupt stop, slide across the carriage floor.

This stool-toting group has been affectionately dubbed the "stool tribe" or 板凳族 bǎndèng zú in Chinese. Typically early birds with long commutes, their need for a seat during the grueling journey is understandable, especially when there's a lack of empty seats on the subway.

Netizen's views about the stool tribe are mixed. Safety concerns are expressed, with some worried about trip hazards if the train suddenly brakes. Yet, sympathy also flows for these stool bearers. As one netizen pointed out, "They usually find a quiet corner, keep to themselves, and don't seem to encroach on others' space."

Another argument is for those with health conditions or pregnant women who might struggle to stand for extended periods. One netizen questioned, "Are pregnant women not allowed to bring a small stool?" Others argue that if luggage and strollers are allowed, why not small stools? Some have proposed more flexible regulations, like restricting stools during rush hour or in crowded carriages.